I know I have a couple students who I’ve lost recently, and I think I’ve lost them to shame. I also feel my own shame about not being better, more of a teacher, for them. I’ll start with the students.
“Brenda, [not her real name], please come back to school,” I implored on her family’s voicemail. I had caught Brenda on the phone before when I called about her attendance. Once she assured me she was sick and staying at home. One or two other times I had left messages. “I know it’s difficult here for you sometimes, but we need you here. Please, just come back. I want to see you, and the other students want to see you. Come back.”
Part of me wanted to get angry. A few years ago I would have said, “Hello, this is Ms. Kasun. Brenda is a very smart student, but please make sure she comes to school. She is risking her future by not coming. What’s more, she’s failing my class and several others because of her absence. Please call me if you have any questions.” My voice would have been a bit shrill, and I would have felt self-important in the message. Skipping my class was somehow a personal insult.
But now I know better. The world my students swim in has little to do with me. Brenda told me that she likes my class and a couple others but hates one or two. We talked about why it was important for her to come to school. She told me her boyfriend, a recent dropout, insists she come to school so she can graduate.
I guess other forces have a more powerful sway on her. I have emailed her counselor and made my last efforts to try and tell her to come back. No more guilt-trips, just a plea to see her again. All I can guess is that the shame is too big for her to call me back, or too big for her to show her face for now.
I called another student, Paul [again, not his real name], who is likely to be expelled. He has been very angry in my class, sometimes with others, sometimes with me. The same student has lived through war atrocities as a child that I can’t begin to imagine. He’s bright, funny, insightful. And now he’s almost gone.
His phone always worked before when I called. This week I tried a couple times. I couldn’t even leave the message I wanted to. “Paul, we miss you at school,” I would have started. “I know you did something you’re upset about, but I’ll still be your teacher,” I would have said. But instead, I got a ring, ring, answer, click. I’m guessing he saw the district phone number on his caller identification. I tried again. Same thing.
It’s possible there was a real phone problem. But I suspect the power of shame for what Paul did–allegedly threatening security personnel and exploding in class, refusing to leave–kept him, or even his family, from wanting to discuss the matter with school personnel.
And there’s my own shame in this. Shame for my limited attempts to make these students’ lives better. Shame for a school system that doesn’t hear and understand these kids. Shame for our collective impotence as a society to help kids who are hurting.
Finally, today’s Washington Post published information about a UNICEF study on child welfare. The US ranks #20 out of 21 wealthy countries in child welfare. Somehow I’m not surprised.